Tuesday, January 24, 2012

Pianist Maurizio Pollini at 70

A bit under the radar now that CDs mean relatively nothing anymore, Maurizio Pollini is celebrating turning 70. Fascinating is how his career has developed over the years. Anyone who had the good fortune to hear his teenage performances of the Chopin Etudes from presumably Italian radio knows that he was about as perfect a pianist as could be imagined. His technique - impeccable. His taste - nearly just right. As balanced as it gets. Testament just released a recording of the Chopin Etudes from a few years later - probably also superb.

Yet as the 1960s and 1970s went by, Pollini became a divisive musician without even realizing it. No, his Nono, Berg and Schoenberg did not cause the problems.... though only his most ardent fans wanted to hear a pianist play such music. A concert pianist playing while a speaker system plays a recording of that pianist playing - only his diehards could like that.

But, the issue developed as Pollini played the core Germanic repertoire and more of the Chopin. Afterall, this was a pianist who stayed away from the vast majority of Russian romantic masterpieces. Solo Rachmaninoff anyone? The Tchaikovsky Concerto, what is that? No, just Beethoven Sonatas, all 5 Concertos, the Brahms Concertos, and quite a bit of Schumann and Schubert. Okay, we'll throw in the Liszt Sonata and a few other virtuoso showpieces - even the detractors will have to listen to me play that! But still, I am the guy for Beethoven, Brahms, Schumann, Schubert and Chopin.

Or am I?

That was the issue. Pianists thought to be excellent typically had a "flair" for that composer. But Pollini was a very "clean" player (as his fans would say) and one who rarely injected individuality and personality into his performances of those composers. This was not Richter playing Beethoven and then Schumann - or Backhaus playing Beethoven and then Schumann, both pianists who changed performance style dramatically depending on the composer. And not a Cortot in Chopin or Schnabel in Beethoven where one says it was a perfect fit.

Actually, Pollini was the "objective" musician who deliberately left out eccentricities and extreme ideas in his performances and instead, chose a very middle of the road, highly polished account of music from the basic repertoire. Perhaps best here was his Schumann Fantasy performance captured on DG - one as well done as nearly all others and yet, always perfectly tasteful. His Chopin Polonaises on DG only have Rubinstein as a serious rival.

But as the 1990s came, Pollini's repertoire (the basic repertoire) became more and more endearing. More and more emerging pianists like Kissin and Volodos were focused on showcasing themselves as virtuosos but never played much Beethoven, no Debussy (Pollini added a little French music to his arsenal and did so quite well), and did not play the same Schumann or Schubert masterpieces that Pollini liked to play. Even today's Lang Lang and Yuja Wang barely play the repertoire that Pollini has much of his career.

Yet, Pollini celebrates his 70th year with sonatas by Beethoven (with Les Adieux and op. 90 among others) and a collection of Chopin works ending with the first Scherzo. Ironically, none of the other "famous" pianists even concertize with this repertoire.

So what happens when you play great works with little competition and you are Pollini? It becomes clearer and clearer that you are invaluable, now and into the future.

Meanwhile, it should be noted that anyone who has heard Pollini in the past 10 years live should attest that only a very very very few pianists can even just play the piano as well - in great music.

It would have been interesting of Prokofiev 7 and Petrushka was not the vast majority of his Russian Repertoire and if he had touched Ravel, a Mozart sonata (imagine!), or a Haydn sonata. Pollini's repertoire is very limited in many ways.

But how wonderful we still have an amazing pianist playing some of the greatest masterpieces, at a time when so many other pianists don't play those works and often, don't play the piano as well either.

Sunday, September 26, 2010

Sokolov - The Real Deal

He may not appear with the Berlin Philharmonic regularly, the Chicago Symphony often, or even Carnegie Hall, but perhaps the world's greatest pianist is only know by those who seriously follow great pianists.  Grigori Sokolov is that pianist.

Maybe his greatest recording is his Bach Art of the Fugue, despite the fact that his fans are in tremendous awe of his technique and ability to take on music ranging from Prokofiev's Piano Sonata No. 7, the Chopin Op. 25 Etudes, and play multiple Beethoven Sonatas all considered as among the finest ever.  Actually, only the Chopin has been issued on CD and "pirates" have developed an underground library of virtually any music Sokolov has played publicly in the past 30 years.  In fact, collectors from as far away as London and Tokyo and all music capitals between are always trying to find the latest Sokolov performances.

While his career has not had all of the glamour as that of pianists such as Perahia, Schiff, or Lang Lang, he still is considered one of the most popular performers in London.  Some people in the music business have stated that Sokolov is not an easy person to work with and therefore, he can be his own worst enemy.

Regardless, the pirates have helped keep Sokolov's legacy alive and his recordings (even pirate ones) illustrate that the world's greatest pianist is not the one most popular, but the one who performs at the highest level.

Lang Lang - The Fake

Fake, v (thesaurus.com) 
to conceal the defects of or make appear more attractive, interesting, valuable, etc., usually in order to deceive

Pianists from the world renowned Curtis Institute have said they witnessed Lang Lang during his student days doing the unthinkable: practicing in front of a mirror.  So what, you ask?  This type of practicing by pianists until Lang Lang was unheard of in the halls of America's leading conservatories and music schools.  Sure, flutists and clarinetists often practice in front of the mirror to work on their technique and yes, it can clearly help them become better performers.  But pianists gain no musical benefit practicing in front of a mirror - after all, they clearly see their hands and any technical issues right in front of them.

Anyone who has seen Lang Lang perform has witnessed the tremendous theatrics and acting jobs the pianist deliberately features in his presentations.  Following in the footsteps of Yo-Y0 Ma and Joshua Bell, Lang Lang makes acting an essential part of his performances in order to portray to the audiences that he understands the music at such a high level.

The fake in all of this is that Lang Lang's music interpretations are NOT at a high level and his playing has been bettered by multiple pianists in virtually all of the works that he performs.  In fact, not only is his playing at a lower level to such pianists as Lipatti or Rubinstein or Janis or a number of great 20th century pianists, his performances of popular repertoire is at a much lower lever than pianists much lesser known than himself - even a pianist like Marc-Andre Hamelin who has never had the opportunity to perform with most of the great orchestras.

Take for example Lang Lang's performance of the Tchaikovsky Piano Concerto No. 1 (http://www.deutschegrammophon.com/special/?ID=langlang-tchaikovsky), Martha Argerich's performances of this concerto (both her thrilling performance with Kondrashin or her tempered performances) make Lang Lang look incredibly dull.  Even Richter and Gilels in this concerto, hardly pianists considered top performers of this work, are at a totally different level.  Kissin's teenage performance provide much more excitement, and even his performance with Karajan (known as a poor conductor in this work) has more life.  Meanwhile, we're not exactly talking about a challenging concerto to play well.

But it does not stop there.  His tour and recording of Chopin's Piano Sonata No. 3 tested the limits of what is acceptable.  The slow movement ranks amongst the slowest ever, and is so slow that it practically comes to a crawl.

Lang Lang's performance of the Liszt Hungarian Rhapsody No. 2 is not nearly the performance that those by Hamelin and Valentina Lisitsa are today.  For those lucky enough to heard pianist Misha Dacic perform the work, they also witnessed a performance at an entirely different level as to what Lang Lang has delivered.

Lang Lang's national public television debut with the Liszt Don Juan Fantasy featured such intense acting on the keyboard that one had to wonder if the acting made it impossible for Lang Lang to put phrases together and perform at a high level.  Many pianists with far less notoriety have taken this work on and provided much greater excitement and intensity.

Ultimately, Lang Lang's greatest limitations are his lack of dynamic range or variety of tone colors.  He is know as a pretty good technician from the standpoint of no work being "too difficult" for him to play.  But, hearing Lang Lang in the concert hall or on recordings provides no evidence of a pianist whose dynamic range, tone colors, or musicianship as anything better than mediocre - even when comparing against today's major pianists.

Unfortunately, today's concert audiences are largely unfamiliar with "good playing."  Fifty years ago, few concert artists acted on stage anywhere near today's Yo-Yo Ma, Joshua Bell, Lang Lang, and Murray Perahia - perhaps only Rudolf Serkin, who makes Lang Lang look like a student musician.

Hopefully one day the public can look past the fake on stage, and listen to the actual piano playing.  There are many other pianists who deserve the attention instead that Lang Lang has received.

Thursday, September 16, 2010

The Immortals

While everyone is going to have their own take on which pianists of the past century are "must hear," experiencing the art of the greatest pianists is the ultimate piano listening experience.  No, one need not necessarily wait until they have been listening to music for decades.  These pianists just based on both their abilities and what they brought to piano playing make each of them a "must hear."


ARGERICH, MARTHA



BACKHAUS, WILHELM
What would have happened if EMI chose Wilhelm Backhaus to record the complete Beethoven Sonatas and not Artur Schnabel.  But there's the impact of record labels back in the 1930s and an example of how the commercial side of classical music can affect how pianists are remembered and respected.  Backhaus was certainly one of the greatest Beethoven interpreters, especially his recording of Les Adieux before World War II.  But, maybe the most amazing day of recording took place when Backhaus walks into a studio in the 1930s, and just a few hours later leaves with a complete unedited performance of the Chopin Etudes, still to this day one of the finest recordings of them in history.

BERMAN, LAZAR
His performances of the Liszt Transcendental Etudes are one of those rare moments of absolute thunder across the keyboard - no pianist ever eclipsed the constant fury, whether in Mazeppa or Chasse Neige or any of the other treacherous etudes.

CORTOT, ALFRED
Perhaps the most moving interpreter of Chopin's piano music.  Rubinstein probably gets all the credit for being the great Chopin player, largely because his more metronomic and polished approach to Chopin's music would forever change the way Chopin is played.  But Cortot's playing was truly spontaneous, showcasing highly free and very individual interpretations for EACH Chopin work he played - unlike Rubinstein's mostly one style fits all.  Compare Cortot and Rubinstein in Chopin's Nocturne Opus 9 No. 2 and Waltz Opus 64 No. 2 - Cortot sounds like (justly so) a genius.  Cortot's Schumann (Kreisleriana for example) is actually not nearly as free as his Chopin, but still is at the highest level.  Musicians and historians often like to joke about Cortot's "wrong notes" (also more evidence of how Rubsintein changed piano player moving forward), yet his performances of the Liszt Sonata, Saint-Saens Etude in the Form of a Waltz, and even some of the Chopin Etudes show a pianist with a dazzling technique - all from unedited performances (unlike the recordings of the vast majority of pianists since 1955). 

GILELS, EMIL
So many people talk about a prodigy and how a particular pianist would become the "next great one."  Most of the time, people are wrong.  In fact, looking back at the vast majority of the great pianists of the past century, one can argue with plenty of evidence that the greatest pianists are already showing their greatness before they could have their first alcoholic drink in the U.S. (age 21).  A perfect example here is Emil Gilels whose Figaro transcription at the age of 18 is the most exciting recording of this virtuoso showpiece - and one of the greatest performances of any transcription ever made.  In the 1950s and early 1960s, Gilels was a pianist on fire with an incredible Beethoven Appassionata, Liszt Sonata, complete set of Beethoven Piano Concertos in Prague, and concluding with the Siloti arrangement of a Bach prelude that he will be forever associated with (it is a MUST hear as opposed to a must hear).  Some music lovers prefer his transition into a much more soulful and less brilliant pianist in the 1970s as his numerous recordings of Beethoven Sonatas for DG and the Brahms Ballades show.  Regardless of which period you prefer, Gilels will also be best noted for being one of the only pianists whose styles of performance nearly went 180 degrees from youth to "maturity." 

GOULD, GLENN
Most people think of Bach when they think of Gould, and it all starts with the Goldberg Variations.  If he never played another piece in his lifetime, his performance would still be remembered as the the first performance when one thinks of solo piano music by Bach (who may not have known what a piano was, but Gould certainly makes it work here).  No pianist ever articulated multiple voices so cleanly, as if each one of his fingers had its own brain directing them.

HOFMANN, JOSEF
While mostly forgotten except by pianophiles, Hofmann may have been the most talented pianist in the past century.  A listen to the Liszt La Campanella leaves the listener in awe as Hofmann's dexterity on the keyboard is jaw dropping.  The slow movements of the Chopin Concertos take the listener on a fascinating journey filled with great spontaneity, back when metronomes and note perfection did not constrain music making.

RICHTER, SVIATOSLAV
The most intriguing pianist for sure - Richter could be both the fiery virtuoso and the highly sensitive musician.  No pianist had the range in different styles of playing that Richter did - just listen to his Beethoven Appassionata, some of his Bach Preludes and Fugues on the DG memoriam, the Schumann Fantasy, Schubert Wanderer Fantasy, and many of the Rachmaninoff Preludes.  Yes, he recorded well beyond his best years.  But it's hard to imagine a more diverse and complete pianist than Richter during the 1958 - 1970 time frame.

RUBINSTEIN, ARTUR
Rubinstein's impact on Chopin playing is not only substantial, it still lives with the majority of pianists who perform his music today.  Instead of using improvising dynamics, tempi, and intepretation like the great Chopin players before 1940 (Cortot, Hofmann, Rosenthal, Friedman, etc.), Rubinstein played Chopin with a steady, consistent tempo and purposefully controlled dynamic contrast to create performances that often did not vary.  Some believe Rubinsteins best Chopin playing comes from the period Cortot and Hofmann were still "competitors."  Those recordings starting in the 1930s for HMV included landmark recordings of the complete Mazurkas, Nocturnes, Scherzi, Polonaises, and two of the finest performances ever of the Piano Concertos.  However, listening to Rubinstein's recordings from the 1960s in stereo provide a special opportunity to hear the legendary pianist in excellent sound, although it traded some of the earlier excitement for a more pleasant view of the music.  His performances from the 1940s and 1950s of many of these works provide a nice happy medium between Rubinstein still having plenty of energy with slightly superior sound to the earliest of his recordings.  Of course with Rubinstein's very extensive library of recorded performances, his earliest recordings of the Beethoven Appassionata and Rachmaninoff Piano Concerto No. 2 are some of the earliest examples of great performances of those works.  Ultimately, it is his Chopin that solidifies his place amongst the immortals.   




.

About Pianist Review

Pianist Review provides a collection of information and insights into the art of pianists, with a primary focus on the most important and/or outstanding pianists.  As classical music has become increasingly competitive and commercialized while its popularity has declined substantially over the past century, important pianists are not always outstanding and outstanding pianists are not always important.  While people can debate whether an artist is important or outstanding, the discussion alone keeps alive the art of piano playing - in the end, supporting the art of the pianist.