Tuesday, January 24, 2012

Pianist Maurizio Pollini at 70

A bit under the radar now that CDs mean relatively nothing anymore, Maurizio Pollini is celebrating turning 70. Fascinating is how his career has developed over the years. Anyone who had the good fortune to hear his teenage performances of the Chopin Etudes from presumably Italian radio knows that he was about as perfect a pianist as could be imagined. His technique - impeccable. His taste - nearly just right. As balanced as it gets. Testament just released a recording of the Chopin Etudes from a few years later - probably also superb.

Yet as the 1960s and 1970s went by, Pollini became a divisive musician without even realizing it. No, his Nono, Berg and Schoenberg did not cause the problems.... though only his most ardent fans wanted to hear a pianist play such music. A concert pianist playing while a speaker system plays a recording of that pianist playing - only his diehards could like that.

But, the issue developed as Pollini played the core Germanic repertoire and more of the Chopin. Afterall, this was a pianist who stayed away from the vast majority of Russian romantic masterpieces. Solo Rachmaninoff anyone? The Tchaikovsky Concerto, what is that? No, just Beethoven Sonatas, all 5 Concertos, the Brahms Concertos, and quite a bit of Schumann and Schubert. Okay, we'll throw in the Liszt Sonata and a few other virtuoso showpieces - even the detractors will have to listen to me play that! But still, I am the guy for Beethoven, Brahms, Schumann, Schubert and Chopin.

Or am I?

That was the issue. Pianists thought to be excellent typically had a "flair" for that composer. But Pollini was a very "clean" player (as his fans would say) and one who rarely injected individuality and personality into his performances of those composers. This was not Richter playing Beethoven and then Schumann - or Backhaus playing Beethoven and then Schumann, both pianists who changed performance style dramatically depending on the composer. And not a Cortot in Chopin or Schnabel in Beethoven where one says it was a perfect fit.

Actually, Pollini was the "objective" musician who deliberately left out eccentricities and extreme ideas in his performances and instead, chose a very middle of the road, highly polished account of music from the basic repertoire. Perhaps best here was his Schumann Fantasy performance captured on DG - one as well done as nearly all others and yet, always perfectly tasteful. His Chopin Polonaises on DG only have Rubinstein as a serious rival.

But as the 1990s came, Pollini's repertoire (the basic repertoire) became more and more endearing. More and more emerging pianists like Kissin and Volodos were focused on showcasing themselves as virtuosos but never played much Beethoven, no Debussy (Pollini added a little French music to his arsenal and did so quite well), and did not play the same Schumann or Schubert masterpieces that Pollini liked to play. Even today's Lang Lang and Yuja Wang barely play the repertoire that Pollini has much of his career.

Yet, Pollini celebrates his 70th year with sonatas by Beethoven (with Les Adieux and op. 90 among others) and a collection of Chopin works ending with the first Scherzo. Ironically, none of the other "famous" pianists even concertize with this repertoire.

So what happens when you play great works with little competition and you are Pollini? It becomes clearer and clearer that you are invaluable, now and into the future.

Meanwhile, it should be noted that anyone who has heard Pollini in the past 10 years live should attest that only a very very very few pianists can even just play the piano as well - in great music.

It would have been interesting of Prokofiev 7 and Petrushka was not the vast majority of his Russian Repertoire and if he had touched Ravel, a Mozart sonata (imagine!), or a Haydn sonata. Pollini's repertoire is very limited in many ways.

But how wonderful we still have an amazing pianist playing some of the greatest masterpieces, at a time when so many other pianists don't play those works and often, don't play the piano as well either.